Winter Driving in Honda Civic Hybrid
Created December 30, 2004, at 1:55 pm by Anonymous
I believe I have heard that the HCH gets worse gas mileage in the winter. I live in Chicago, IL and I am experience this reduced gas mileage, but I don't know if this is due to changed driving conditions or the weather (or both). I typically got ~49mpg during the spring, summer, and fall. Now I am getting around 40. Does anyone have any tips for getting better gas mileage in the winter?
Also, I always thought that the only thing that would prevent the auto-stop from working (when your temp-gauge reads in the middle) is if the "ECON" light is off (e.g., front defroster is on or A/C is being used with ECON off). However, I have noticed that, even if the ECON light is on and the temp gauge reads in the middle, the auto-stop will still not work. I have to turn the fan setting to "OFF" in order to get auto-stop to work. I have only noticed this since the outside temperature has dropped below 30 degrees F, so I am assuming it has something to do with the outside temp. Any ideas on this?
Stephen Fenwick



7 years ago
first, if you guys are like california you have "winter blend gas" going on. i don't understand it but for several years (even before my hybrid) i saw a drop in total miles per tank between summer & winter. i thought for a while this was brand related (mobil or arco or whoever) but eventually saw the summer-winter blrnd switch across all brands of gas. it occured once coincident with me getting an oil change & tune up which really made me wonder what was going on...
i don't understand how a worse mileage blend of gas can somehow be better for us. anyone know the details?
for the econo button i only see it "off" by my choice or by the use of the defroster. i guess there is a law somewhere that can not let the defroster air be disrupted by stop & go like the usual hybrid setting.
see ya
7 years ago
In response to "Winter Blend gasoline". The reason drivers in cold regions get worse mileage from Winter blend fuel is b/c the fuel is cut with an anti- gel agent. The anti gel has less BTU energy than gasoline so it lowers the overall energy of the gasoline.
Also in cold weather any engine is less efficient until it gets up to operating temperature. Just another 5-10minute delay in reaching operating temp. can lower mileage 5% or more.
Even once it is at operating temp. when outside air is below 60F engines are not as efficient.
As the temp. keeps dropping, efficiency goes down even more.
There is not much you can do about this winter issue. I have seen Insight owners blocking most of the radiator grill with dense foam to keep radiator warmer.
7 years ago
this wintering gas issue is fascinating. as are jeff's comments that below 60 degrees all engines underperform.... That sounds like pretty poor performance across the boards. I would understand it it were below 32 f.
why is this the case. seems shocking that you can buy a $12 insulated lunch bag that controls temperatures for hours, but car makers can't hold performance below 60 degrees?
7 years ago
this wintering gas issue is fascinating. as are jeff's comments that below 60 degrees all engines underperform.... That sounds like pretty poor performance across the boards. I would understand it it were below 32 f.
why is this the case. seems shocking that you can buy a $12 insulated lunch bag that controls temperatures for hours, but car makers can't hold performance below 60 degrees?
7 years ago
Will blocking the radiator help winter fuel economy? I'm sure Honda disapproves, but is there a recommended way to block it, without damaging the radiator or the engine?
7 years ago
I've seen some Insight owners use a packing foam pressed in between the outside grill openings.
==========
Foam
==========
Foam
==========
If the above equal marks are your grill, the foam is slid in between the grill strips. Not all openings are blocked, about 50% are. I'm up in the cold NorthEast.
I guess the object is too keep the radiator warm.
If your car warms up quicker and stays warm. Then the gas motor will shut off at stops/ red lights
as it does in the summer. ie better fuel mileage.
Do you remember seeing school buses with the "bras" covering the grills? That was so the darn bus would throw some heat in the winter.
7 years ago
Some reasons I read about the Temperature issue causing a drop in economy are:
Cold engine is less efficient. Cold weather causes longer warmup times.
More rolling resistance from your tires.
Cold air is denser, causing a higher coefficient of drag.
Last thing car designer said was optimium air temp. for best fuel/air mix was about 60F.
Think this all was in either MotorTrend or Car and driver in the last couple months.
7 years ago
I own an '05 HCH as well and I live in Northern MI so I am also in very cold winter conditions for many months out of the year. My HCH was bought in November before it became it became normal to have below 40 temperatures and my Auto Stop function worked at almost every stop.
I've read in quite a few places that the Auto Stop feature does rely on the outside temperature being 40'ish and above but I've gotten mine to work in the 30's with a fully warmed up car.
You also have the issue of tire pressure which I've asked about many times before but cant get a solid answer on. My HCH came with Dunlop's set at 30psi at the dealership. I brought this up to 35psi on all four tires and noted a small increase in MPG but then the cold set in.
I've seen other's somewhere talk about running their '04 HCH at 38psi on all for and even one guy who ran his at 42psi on all four. The tires are rated a lot higher than this but that seems somewhat dangerous for those of us in hard winter climates.
As for the radiator vent blocking I would agree and disagree. In theory it seems like a benefit to keeping the radiator warmer than normal but in practice I can see some dangerous things happening with melting foam/insulation and etc. Just a little to paranoid to try this on my brand new car.
Right now I'm at 3K total miles and I'm averaging 34.4 MPG for my current tank of gas running mostly highway miles and my lifetime MPG is at 35.6. These are not astronomical numbers at all and my driving habits have been modified from the get go.
The only thing I can think of that is limiting me out of the 40's like so many other HCH drivers I see is the winter conditions, possible tire pressure, winter blend gas, and improved MPG after my first oil change at 5K.
I'd be real interested in hearing what others with the same model vehicle have to say who also drive in similar conditions. I'm a bit disappointed in the lack of websites about the '04 and '05 HCH as opposed to the Insight and Prius.
7 years ago
How does the HCH get worse mileage than the regular civic? I would be at the dealership asking why I paid $2000 premium for a hybrid?
Alot of people are getting a rude awaking when winter roles around. They are finding out the overly optimistic EPA mileage numbers are not atainable in the winter.
Hybrids are great in warm climates and city driving, but they don't live up to the mileage claims in other real world conditions.
Previously I drove a VW Jetta TDI (turbodiesel)
that returned 50mpg highway year round.
Now I', driving the Passat TDi it's rated at 38mpg high, but I'm getting more like 40-42mpg @ 70mph.
Diesels are a proven, long lasting car with a minium premium for great economy and power.
7 years ago
A non-hybrid will take almost the same hit in the winter as a hybrid anyway. All cars get worse gas mileage in extreme cold. The Prius and HCH are efficient not just because of the hybrid mechanism and auto-stop, but because they have very advanced engines that are efficient in all operating conditions.
7 years ago
They have a database over at greenhybrid dot com that shows the current average from 60 HCH's to be at 47MPG, 22 Insight owners average 63MPG, and 96 Prius owners average 48MPG.
8 days ago I just filled 11 gallons of fuel in my HCH. My fuel is $.23 cheaper / gallon than diesel, easier to find and I achieved a calculated tank of 59MPG.
7 years ago
Most reasonable people, who care about mileage and emissions and keeping the planet livable for us and our children, hope for and believe that any good automotive alternative that improves fuel economy and reduces emission is a good thing.
That's why people on this forum are apt to say:
- hybrids are good
- clean diesel is good
- hybrid-clean diesels will be good
- hydrogen will be good if it lives up to its promise
When people come into this forum and say, "my diesel is great, and your hybrids suck," it adds nothing to the discussion. And it probably makes diesel proponents cringe, when they see illogical and unnecessarily inflammatory posts like the one earlier in this thread, because it only serves to diminish intelligent discussion about the pros and cons of diesel, instead focusing on misinformation and hyperbole.
That's what is nice about this forum -- for the most part it is frequented by reasonable folks who would rather engage in a profitable discussion, as opposed to other forums which are more often filled with "I'm great, you're stupid" posts like the one earlier.
So my recommendation to the earlier poster is to visit www.californiagasprices.com, or www.edmunds.com, where you can engage in slagging off your opponents. This forum is for folks who just want to talk about hybrids, fuel economy, or whatever, in a reasonable and gracious manner.
7 years ago
I've had my HCH for about 14 months now. I was getting a lot of bragging out my mileage until my first 7,000 mile oil change, tire rotation. Now I get 43-44mpg instead of average 49mpg. I am due for another oil change and the dealer agreed that something is wrong! Last winter which was fairly cold in a consistent way, unlike this winter, I was getting the better mileage and that was while the car was breaking in and I was learning how to do the hybrid driving technique!
So, I am convinced that in my case something is wrong (please please please!). Otherwise I will be forced to acknowledge that I am really just a do-gooder instead of a cheapskate!
7 years ago
I'm not sure if you had increased the pressure in your tires, in order to improve mileage, before your tire rotation; but if you did, then they probably put the tires back to the recommended value (30 or 32 PSI) when they did that service.
Many people run their tires at 38 or so PSI in order to increase mileage (for tires with a max PSI of 44).
7 years ago
Another thing to consider is the type of oil that was used in the oil change. If it is different than what was used earlier, then that might be the cause of the mileage drop as well.
7 years ago
I bought my '04 HCH in April. At first my highway mileage (65 MPH on I-80) was about 47 MPG. At it has aged (now has 13,000 miles) the mileage has dropped steadily. Before the cold of winter set in, I was getting about 40 MPG under the same driving conditions as when it was new and getting 47 MPG. City mileage has dropped from 38 to 31 MPG. The Honda dealer has told me (twice) that everything is up to specs and there's nothing that can be done...........sorry, Charlie! Contacting Honda customer service in San Diego got the same results. I believe there is a problem with the IMA, but they deny any problems. If this is the way Honda backs their products, it will be the last Honda product I buy.
7 years ago
One thing to keep in mind is that all cars get worse gas mileage in the winter. I have always kept track of my cars's gas mileage and have noticed anywhere from 5% to 10% drop in winter (Dayton, Cleveland, Ohio). (I don't have any data yet on my '05 Prius, which I hope to pick up in 10 days)
The winter drop is more noticeable on a hybrid vehicle because your gas mileage is so much better. Few people worry about an SUV dropping from 20 to 18 mpg in the winter, but a drop from 50 to 45 mpg is something we swear over.
Another possibility is those of us who are more conscious of saving energy are more likely to notice even a little drop.
Rest assured, everbody's vehicle is getting worse gas mileage in the winter time...so our payback is still positive.
7 years ago
Your problem may not be related to this at all, but there is one other thing you might consider. I notice that you are located in San Diego; here in California we get the "benefit" of having oxygenated gas during the winter (November-March), which not only raises the price, but also significantly decreases our MPG.
The purpose of the oxygenation is to reduce emissions in older vehicles; at least that is what I have read. The unfortunate side effect is that we all pay in terms of decreased gas mileage. I can't wait for spring to see if things get better...
7 years ago
I live in the Great White North (ie Canada) and I'm interested in going hybrid.
In addidtion to gasoline / internal combustion efficiency issues, I have concerns about battery efficiency in colder climates that have average winter temps of 0 deg Celsius or lower (thats 32 deg F for you guys south of the 49th parallel).
Is there hybrid performance data available for cold / extreme cold conditions?
7 years ago
32°F (or 0°C for you in USA state #51) should have no affect on the batteries. besides, they ride in the backseat & are comfy.
it's the -45°F that i would worry about. (-49°C). that's the temperature limit usually of commercially designed products.
while i suspect that low temps have already been considered by honda & toyota (who know's what ford or GM think about), you get too low & batteries just stop.
--- i missed out on some really great sunset shots of the grand canyon once becuase my camera battery just died as it got colder...
see ya
steve
7 years ago
I just added about 8 lbs to each tire to bring them up to 33 lbs each (they were down to 25 lbs due to the cold weather), and now I am getting around 43 MPG. Much better! I never knew tire pressure made such a difference.
Now Springtime holds that much more excitement -- warm weather, and I get back my right to brag about my 51 MPG!!!
ps-- the manual says that the auto-stop does not function when a thermometer in the dashboard reads 32 fahrenheit. The thermometer is outside the car, but I bet having the car warmed up can tip the scales on this reading so you can get it to shut off if it is, say, 15-20 degrees outside.
7 years ago
I had a shop tell me that the HCH takes a different oil and that he would have to charge me more to do an oil change. A whole $10.00 more. Is this right? I'm not convinced just yet.
7 years ago
Doug,
I've heard the same thing about the HCH. I'll be going in for my 1st scheduled oil change at 5K in about a month or so.
Rumor tells me that my MPG will go up after this change but I'm anxious to find out myself. Currently I have check my tire pressure because the harsh cold weather is killing my MPG right now.
Only getting between 34 - 38, and that was an improvmnent over past months in the cold weather for me.
7 years ago
i got an oil change with a free car wash & no extra anything.
i can't imagine any reason why they would think the cost would be different then a "regular" car. the basic engine is a plain old gas engine.
did you have an extreme look of inocence on your face?
see ya
7 years ago
"Regular" oil would mean over the counter Penzoil or similar petro-based 10W-30 oil. The HCH is supposed to use 5W-20 if I recall correctly. Still petro based (rather than synthetic) but more expensive than 10W-30.
For best protection in cold climates, you should bring your own oil, and I would suggest Mobil 1 0W-20. That's what I use in my Civic. It's about $5/quart and you'll need around 4 quarts or so.
7 years ago
With regard to mileage, my 2004 HCH puchased 9 months ago averages 40.8. I notice that whenever my husband drives it (he has a 2 hour all-highway commute), the average goes down. And whenever we're back to city driving (we live in Chicago), the average increases. I haven't noticed a difference in winter in terms of mileage however. The Honda salesman did tell us that the ECON button does not work in winter below a certain temperature, and said something about it being a good thing because you don't want your engine to cut and not restart because of the cold. It did go on once this winter but I'm not sure why.
7 years ago
I have owned my 04 Civic Hybrid since Feb 04. I have also noticed a decrease of mileage during the winter. I have done some thinking, and here is what I have determeined.
-The engine will run on all 4 cylinders until it is fully heated up. Because it is colder outside, this will take longer and so more fuel is wasted. As I believe it says in the manual, the engine will shut off cylinders depending on the current throttle/load and engine temp., so even if you are cruising at 55, all 4 cylinders will continue to operate until full temperature is acheived. Try and avoid short trips in the cold.
-The econ feature isn't supposed to work when the outside temp is below freezing, so no auto-off in the cold means a huge decrease in overall gas mileage. I went from getting 48mpg in the fall, to 38mpg during the coldest parts of the winter.
-Check you tire pressure. I live in Chicago, and on the my first full gas tank in cold weather I got a miserable 33mpg. The culprit? The temperature change caused all my tires to lose about 5psi. My next tank's mileage increased to 37mpg.
-The initial start-up/idle is killer. Don't be stingy though! Although idling absolutly destroys your average mpg, it is no excuse to not let your engine warm up. Remember that the rule of thumb is to let your engine run for a minimum of 30 seconds in warm weather, and at least 60 seconds in cold.
-The auto-off feature will also not work when you have the defroster on. I believe that this is due to the a/c automatically turning on. If you pay attention, you'll notice that when you have the fan speed on auto and then switch the defroster on (not the defroster for the rear window, the defroster/defogger for the fron windshield and side windows), the econ light automatically turns off. When you turn the knob from defroster back to auto, the a/c light comes on. Basically, when you tell the car to automatically control you defrost speed at whatever temperature you have set, the a/c automatically turns on to help clear up the windeshields, also disabling the auto-off feature. The same thing happens when you select the defroster/floor vent option.
Somebody in there said they got their oil changed at 7,000 miles... Why? I thought you were supposed to have that done every 5,000 miles. At least that's what my dealer and the instruction manual says.
7 years ago
MO:
After reading your message I can tell you this: The reason the mileage drops when your husband drives his 2 hour commute on the highway is because he is speeding. Cruising at 55mph in normal summer weather netted me an average of 53.5 mpg. Cruising at 70mph nets an average of 46.5 mpg. That 's a huge difference, caused by higher engine rpm (2200@55 versus 2900@70 I think) and aerodynamics. Once a car passes 65 mph, aerodynamics dramatically decrease, causing much more wind resistance and more load on your engine. Not 100% sure on this, but cruising at 80 brings the average to about 43mpg if not less. Ask your husband how fast he's going.
7 years ago
For people noticing a decrease in gas milage after 7-10k miles, besides cold weather, gel in gas, tire pressure, etc, could it be a reduction in the battery capacity, and the controller is using the engine more? Maybe the new battery allowed more electric drive? Just a thought.
7 years ago
I don't think the guy talking about the diesel cars was saying "hybrids suck, diesels rule". He was just stating his preference for diesels since he's had good results with them no matter what the season. That isn't allowed? Attacking him isn't conductive to reasonable discussion.
Anyway, back to the winter fuel issue. Someone posted that in the winter California has oxygenated fuel that reduces emissions. I think they have the seasons reversed. The cleaner burning gas is required in the summer months since that is when air pollution is worse and the higher amounts of UV light help form ozone. So if anything, your should see worse mileage in the summer from this type of gas. I think it has more ethanol in it and it does cost more.
I'd be more willing to believe the decreased mileage is a result of the battery charge/discharge cycle being less efficient due to temperature, the car taking longer to warm up, and the lack of econ mode kicking in. Also, gas doesn't get anti-gel in all areas. You'd have to be in a seriously cold area to get gas with much anti-gel. It's not like diesel. So I doubt this is the issue with most people here.
7 years ago
When are you all going to wake up and relize HYBRIDS DON'T WORK!!IN THE LONG RUN.I have a Diesel and YES I take a hit in the winter but GUESS what I still get 44mpg in the winter.Wake up use Biodiesl and Think Diesel>>>>
7 years ago
Why put Diesels down.thay get BETTER MPG'S last longer.get 740 in the city driving alone to a tank and 15gal tank can use Biodiesel were a gas car can not.Soo Why is every Soo anti Diesel.
7 years ago
Wagonman, actually there's nowhere on earth that would need anti-gel in the gasoline. Regular gasoline has a gel temp somewhere around -100F. There's not really anywhere on Earth that gets that cold, at least not anyplace you'd be likely to drive a vehicle that didn't have an insulated gas tank.
Diesel on the other hand has gel temps as high as +32F to +20F for summer blends and some winter blends will only go down to -20F or so without very serious additional additivies above and beyond what were already in the mix from the pump.
Diesel is extremely dirty in it's nature thanks to the fact diesels don't have throttlebodies. They run extremely lean in all normal conditions and this causes emission levels that are 10 to 20 times higher than a normal gasoline car of similar output. Technology is improving to clean up diesels, but because of it's lack of a throttlebody, it will always be inherently much harder to clean up.
Biodiesel is only marginally more cost effective than Ethanol, and B100 gells around 32F. Ethanol gels well below -100F since it's effectively pure alcohol. Between the two, ethanol is a lot easier to use, although B100 may be a bit cheaper to produce on a massive scale. Sucks to be you if you live anywhere that gets below 32F though since it would have to be loaded up with anti-gel additives, increasing the cost even further and reducing the overall efficiency.
7 years ago
I'm sure glad that I bought a Jetta TDI (diesel).
With biodiesel thinned with anti-gel kerosene, I'm only getting 46 mpg cruising at 85 mph 120 miles each day. Best of all, NO BATTERIES REQUIRED and 40-50% less CO2 (greenhouse gas) emissions than a regular gas powered engine.
7 years ago
I'm sure glad that I bought a Jetta TDI (diesel).
With biodiesel thinned with anti-gel kerosene, I'm only getting 46 mpg cruising at 85 mph 120 miles each day. Best of all, NO BATTERIES REQUIRED and 40-50% less CO2 (greenhouse gas) emissions than a regular gas powered engine.
7 years ago
I've had a HCH for 18 months-23,000 miles now. I keep track of my mileage with the trip computer for each trip and note the mpg and what conditions I experienced. Here are my observations about mpg:
The trip computers (both) read about 10% too high compared with the MPG from gas receipts.
When I drive it in mixed driving spring/fall no A/C I get 51-52 mpg on a tank (Once I got 57mpg)
When my wife drives it she gets about 42-44 mpg
Temps below 50F reduce mpg by about 5%, temps below 40F (thankfully rare here in S. Texas) reduce mpg by about 15%
Running th a/c in summer reduces mpg by about 15%.
In stop-n-go driving in the city I only get about 37-38 mpg and with my style of driving it is almost impossible to keep any charge in the batteries.
By far the largest impact on my mpg are traffic conditions. It is 17 miles commute to work and that includes the international bridge. It is mixed town/highway driving. If I get good lights the trip will read 65-68 mph (4 times it has exceeded 70). However, if the lights go against me (there are 14 on my route) the trip will read 53-57 mpg. Coming home where there is always a wait on the bridge the trip will read 49-55 mpg. All of these numbers are inflated by the long coasting periods I have when getting off the highway portion. Basically, despite the regenerative braking, by far the biggest drain on mpg is the number of times I have to accelerate from a standing stop. Back in the late '70's there was a woman nicknamed 'featherfoot' because she could coax fantastic mpg out of any car she drove - even the fuel hogs of the day. She was famous - even being featured in magazines. It is possible to get a combined total of 25% fuel savings for FREE, with no new technology, just by airing up tires on a regular basis and improving the braking/acceleration components of our driving habits. Cities and counties could contribute as well by synchronizing stoplights and improving traffic flow although they have so far shown little tendency to do that.
7 years ago
Do I detect a bit of DIESEL ENVY among gas-electric hybrid owners?
Competing technologies are largely at a crossroads right now. I'm looking more to the end of the decade to see where things are at. The real-world economy of gas-electric hybrids will be well known by then. Long term reliability and longevity plus the environmental issues will be well known too. It will be interesting to see what power train developments happen over the coming years.
In Europe, Diesel passenger are all the rage over there, now exceeding 50% of all cars on the road there and make up 2/3 of new car sales. In the high-end expensive luxury car segment, the penetration is around 90% and growing. It has been adopted as the practical and greener alternative to gasoline. Greener in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, less crude oil consumption, and more environmentally friendly in terms of the total energy cycle when you consider where gas and Diesel fuel come from when you factor in the energy input into the refining process. Diesels also can run on alternative fuels such as Bio-Diesel, and you can even make it yourself at home from french fry oil if you wanted to. I'm currently unaware of any gas-electric hybrid on the market yet that can run on fuel you can make at home in your kitchen if we were to be hit with another gas crunch like back in the 1970s.
Right now, I drive a 2002 VW Golf TDI 5-speed and get 47MPG consistently during sustained agressive highway driving at 80-85MPH. It gets it's published EPA's mileage numbers even while doing everything you're not supposed to do with a gas-electric hybrid to get best MPGs. If I "babied" it instead instead of driving it hard all the time, it can easily EXCEED its published EPA numbers!
I drive about 1000 miles per week in my work commute plus maintaining a life outside the workplace. Because I'm a driving enthusiast and I drive a lot, there are fundamentally 3 reasons why I chose a modern European-designed turbodiesel car over a gasoline-electric hybrid: Economy, Longevity, and Performance. It's able to offer the blend without compromising its "car" features to get GAS mileage improvements alone. One thing overlooked in the diesel vs. hybrid discussions is the fun to drive factor. VW TDIs are easy and fun to drive.
At 145k miles currently on the odometer, I'm not worried about it's continued reliability and longevity. In terms of performance, the performance is better than ever and still improving. As a lot of gasoline engines including gas hybrid engines begin to show signs of weakened low-end torque, my diesel engine is just entering its prime of life. Diesels definitely have the upper hand when it comes to longevity.
In the winter, I take a 2-3MPG hit because of winterized diesel fuel alone, not because the car is running any less efficiently. In terms of performance, it actually performs its best during the coldest part of the winter. Colder air is denser air and the turbocharger does a better job of getting more air into the engine for better combustion. It hauls arse best in the wicked cold air with ony a minor MPG hit from the winterized fuel.
For putting around town in stop/go traffic, I still prefer the Diesel. It takes very little fuel to idle a Diesel, unlike a gasser. When decelerating in gear, fuel injection is ZERO until the RPMs come down to where fuel has to be injected to maintain RPM under load. It consumes about 5 milliliters per minute of idling (as reported by my engine's ECU via OBD-II diagnostic software). That's only a couple of spoonfuls of fuel per minute, not enough to worry about! The auto-stop feature of gas-electric hybrids is unnecessary with a Diesel. I'm still able to get around 45MPG while doing lots of stop/go city driving. Diesels are relatively insensitive to driving patters and barely sip fuel at idle.
In terms of safety when fueling, Diesel is far safer to handle than gasoline. It doesn't produce explosive vapors that can ignite easily. It's known that liquid Diesel fuel will actually extinguish a lighted match. Don't try this at home with gasoline!
I'm not going to get excited about hybrid technologies until DIESEL-electric hybrids start appearing. MPGs and 1000+ mile tank ranges will become the norm when that happens. Non-hybrid Diesels in Europe already quicker than their gasoline counterparts while delivering better MPGs too. The non-hybrid VW Lupo already gets 81MPG(US). The new Honda Accord Diesel is already setting new world records for MPGs and performance. Too bad we'll never get any of these cars in the USA.
After owning and driving a modern turbodiesel car, I will not own another GASOLINE powered car again if I can help it, including gas-electric hybrids. Once you convert to DIESEL, you don't go back to GASOLINE. It doesn't make sense. With DIESEL, I can be totally free from OPEC if necessary by running Bio-Diesel.
I'm currenly buying a 2005 Jeep Liberty Common-Rail Diesel (160HP, 295 lb-ft torque) as a second vehicle. No more gassers for me!
7 years ago
Because of the sulpher in US gas, diesels smell bad, and put out 20 times as much noxious polutants as a Prius. Love your diesel all you want, but you're doing the environmental damage of TWENTY Prius'.
Even without sulpher, the incredibly lean mixtures that diesel uses will never be as clean as a gasoline engine. Anything you do to clean up a diesel, you can do to make a gasoline engine even cleaner. As far as emissions goes, diesel can never be as clean. It can get close, and with low sulpher it can at least be a heck of a lot cleaner than it is now, but it can never surpass gasoline.
6 years ago
quote: "Do I detect a bit of DIESEL ENVY among gas-electric hybrid owners? "
Not if you speak English and can read at a sixth-grade level.
Look, everybody knows about the advantages and disadvantages of hybrids and diesel. Intelligent people come here to discuss the pros and cons of each. We don't come to this forum to hear people SHOUT that their DIESEL or HYBRID is better than the other person's DIESEL or HYBRID.
I am a HCH owner who loves my car, and gets 44-52 MPG easily. And I am actually considering a diesel for my next car purchase, to replace our other car, once diesels become clean and stop spewing so much junk into the air that they cannot even be sold in my state. But after reading rants like yours and the previous ones, I am less inclined than ever to do so. If your intention is to entice people towards diesel, then I'm afraid you are probably having the opposite effect.
6 years ago
David:
The oil change interval in the Civic Hybrid is 10,000 miles for normal conditions, and 5,000 for "severe" conditions. Your dealer would like you to think you're driving in severe conditions, as they'll make twice as much money off of you. Log on to OwnerLink at Honda.com, and read what they have to say there. Honda themselves says that very few people actually qualify for "severe" conditions. I have followed the 10,000 mile interval since I got the car in May, 2002.
The oil used in the Civic Hybrid is 0w-20, *not* 5w-20 (that's for regular Civics, etc.). If your car was refilled with heavier oil, your fuel efficiency might be compromised (also make sure it wasn't overfilled, etc.).
And yes, the oil change for the hybrids using 0w-20 is about $10 more at most Honda dealerships. They do not stock the oil in bulk and so most dealers must crack open quarts, just like you and me. Their cost is more expensive that way.
peace,
Linda (owns two hybrids -- an '03 HCH and an '01 Prius -- first editions of both!)
6 years ago
Winter driving in a honda civic "hybrid"sucks. I ended up taking my civic back and getting a dodge neon srt-4 because the new hybrids dont run in cold conditions. Overall they SUCK........
6 years ago
Ah, Milo is apparently trolling since what he didn't mention is that the SRT-4 gets about 15mpg in the hands of most owners. Car and Driver managed only 14mpg from theirs. He likely has never owned either car he claims to own, and certainly the demographic for a Civic Hybrid owner (generally mature, well-educated) and an SRT-4 owner (teenage street racers) are about as far from each other as it gets.
6 years ago
Photo, have you ever heard "never say never". You're making a pretty strong statement on something that you can't possible know the outcome of.
They may figure out a way to make diesels cleaner than gasser, you never know. They might also find out that the benzene and smaller particulates with gas actually cause more harm than the larger particulates of diesel engines.
6 years ago
There is a lot more to poor gas milage in the winter than mearly the fuel. Friction from the cold means that your vehicle will not roll as easily . . . resulting in . . . it takes more fuel to move it . . .
6 years ago
There is a lot more to poor gas milage in the winter than merely the fuel. Friction from the cold means that your vehicle will not roll as easily . . . resulting in . . . it takes more fuel to move it . . .
6 years ago
no - in southern california we're "cold" with 48 degree nights.
lower mileage.
it's the gas...
see ya
6 years ago
thanks for everyone's responses, I have to say, I "got into it" with Honda central and they have responded by having a chat with my dealer. I am the only HCH they service and my problems did start in september (I am in New Jersey) when I had my second oil change and we had a pretty warm fall. I am suspicious that the wrong oil was used. It is recommended to be 0W if I am correct. The gas does have the MBTA or whatever here in the winter, and my tires should be checked. But I am still a little shocked that Honda is not upfront about this. Though I do believe in my heart that car dealers are not far up the chain from pond scum.
I still like my car, I especially enjoy the idiots who charge up to me when I am driving just above the speed limit in the slow lane and think that I;m not going fast enough (please) when they see the "hybrid" tag.
And regarding that person who drives 85 miles an hour? what is that? have you heard of safe driving? I hope you know how fast your brakes will safely stop you, and I hope you aren't driving in New Jersey!
6 years ago
katen - you need to head west one day. i left NJ some 25 years ago & never looked back.
the speed limits in arizona, nevada, montana, the dakotas, etc are all 75 mph. it's easy to just cruise at 80 for hours.
and the roads don't have potholes the size of tree trunks every 40 feet.
it's our car's basic shaping that cuts the milage at those speeds. too bad cars still do not address the underbody wind drag that robs still further efficiency.
see ya
6 years ago
On Low Winter miles per gallon:
All vehicals are less efficient in the winter, especially in the northern climates. There are many things your car is required to do/ more frequently in the winter. These include:
Heating: blower motor and the pump(some models) Heated seats.
Defoggers: Electric - Back window, mirrors, Front +more blower hours
Lights = Electricity = Engine hours - (less hours of daylight
More power to drive thru snow and in Cold: Increased wheel drag thru snow - Batteries and Engines less efficient at cold temperatures
This all can be described as the First Law of Thermodynamics (for you Engineers) - the conservation of Energy - There is no loss - Just conversion: ie If you use it, you pay for it!
Legislators failing to know the above created the all Electric car sales quotas that passed without being met. This legislation delayed the introduction of Hybrids and caused much consternation.
You can increase your fuel milage by keeping you car in heated spaces, waiting to drive until the roads are plowed, not using the heat, defoggors, or lights, but I like using all.
Good Luck
6 years ago
Regarding the cost of oil changes for the HCH: my reputable dealer charged me $10 more, they said, because the hybrid uses synthetic oil. I would have liked to have heard about that from the salesman before I bought the car, but oh well.
Regarding the frequency of oil changes: I got mixed opinions about whether I was operating under "extreme" conditions or not. By reading the criteria myself, I judged that I was, and anyway I'd rather spend a bit more to ensure the long life of my car.
Regarding the overall drop in efficiency during the winter: the explanations here make sense and confirm my own observations. Thanks!
6 years ago
Overall I see a lot of disappointment with hybrid mileage. I agree that hybrids make SOME sense in the city where the regenerative braking works to your advantage. But I have a 1000 km/week highway commute. A diesel is the only sensible alternative for me. We own two, a Jetta wagon that gets 1200 km/tank (750 miles), and a Passat which gets 1000 km/tank (600 miles). The Passat has consistently averaged 34-38 mpg year-round. Might I point out that this is a fair sized family car with 134 hp and 247 lb-ft of torque. The Jetta, having a manual transmission, does even better, about 40-45 mpg (depends largely on whether we have the roof rack and ski box or bike racks on top). Its engine produces 100 hp and 177 lb-ft of torque.
The big beef I have with hybrids though, is economics. Honda wants about $23000 for a top-of-the-line Civic Si sedan, (automatic) and an extra $5500 for a hybrid Civic (Canadian $). A pretty substantial premium. I can get a nicely equipped Jetta GLS for about $26500 or about $1500 over the gas GLS. The premium for the Passat over a gas model was only about $300.
Then check out residual values at the Canadian Black Book site (you have to do this through a automaker's site). Factor in the resale value, and the hybrid looks like a net economic loss over driving a gas Civic. A 2-year old Civic Hybrid fetches about $15500 at trade-in. A 2-y.o. Jetta TDI sedan fetches about $19500. A straight Civic LX sedan (no Si in 2003) would fetch $14200 (on a LX that sells for about $20000).
Total capital loss to run a TDI for 2 years: $7000.
Total capital loss to run a Civic LX for 2 years: $5800
Total capital loss to run a Civic hybrid for 2 years: $12500.
To put it plainly, a hybrid makes very little economic sense with these numbers. The fuel economy gain over a base Civic would require many, many years of driving to pay for the price premium of nearly $7000 in 2 years. For an environmentally sound technology to catch on, it has to make economic sense. Most middle-income families do not have the luxury of blowing $7 grand just to be "green" when buying a car. I also haven't factored in the big unknown with hybrids: the cost of battery replacement.
On the other hand, a diesel, does pay back relatively quickly both with high resale value and great fuel economy vs an equivalent gas model.
In terms of environmental soundness, diesels and hybrids both have their advantages and disadvantages. In terms of getting the best overall reduction in greenhouse gases, diesels are the best bet due to the operating effiency, AND the refining efficiency of the fuel. And who can honestly say what the environmental impact of the disposal of large batteries laden with heavy metals will have? Even if recycled, you have to factor in the energy expenditure in the recycling process.
Diesels on the other hand have issues with particulates and NOx. These are more quality-of-life issues than destroy-the-planet issues like greenhouse gases. But they are nonetheless important from a health perspective.
All said though, I think we diesel and hybrid types can agree that we have a common environmental enemy: large SUVs!
Mike G.
6 years ago
Mike,
Yours was a very intelligent, reasonable, well written and productive explanation of diesel versus hybrid issues. I'm personally a Honda Civic Hybrid owner -- very happily so, with mileage over 50 mpg highway-- but I am also interested in the promotion of other technologies that help to make the planet cleaner, and reduce dependence on oil, especially from hotspots like the Middle East.
My state, California, will not even allow diesels to be sold (e.g. the VW TDI models), until they address the particulate and NOx issues. When VW does this -- hopefully soon -- it will likely be time for me to replace my other car, and I will choose a hybrid or diesel, depending on input from here and elsewhere.
So thanks for your post, which has given me food for thought.
And as you say, we (diesel and hybrid) are on the same side, and "in this together." I think there is room for both technologies, and even possibly a need for both, in order to more fully address the issues that we all face now and in the future.
6 years ago
Mike G.
One other thing that some folks need to take into account when purchasing a car is incentives and tax breaks. My state, Connecticut, recently passed enacted a law that exempts hybrid cars (only the civic, prius and insight) from state sales tax (equivalent to $1,300). The U.S. still has a federal tax break on hybrid cars that enables most buyers to save $500 to $600 on taxes. These two tax breaks resulted in a total savings on the purchase of my new Honda Civic of $1,900. This resulted in my civic being only $100 more than a comparably equipped non-hybird civic (one with side impact airbags, etc.). The decision for me and other folks in progressive states like connecticut is easy, even when the financials are considered.
6 years ago
Mike -
I almost forgot, an added bonus of the new CT law is that the sales tax is also exempt for the purchase of used >40 MGP HEVs through 2008. This means that if i sell my hybrid before 2008 the resale value may hold better (due to the sales tax incentive) and then i can purchase another before the exemption expires. Hopefully other states will follow Connecticut's lead.
6 years ago
I bought a hybrid civic in nov 2004 and now have 10k miles. I am getting 32-36 mpg. I took it into the dealer and just got dumb looks as to what is going on. A friend of mine has an accord and claims he is getting 28 mpg consistently. Feel like a fool being spoken to by fools.
6 years ago
yes, people do speed up your tail when you are going above the speed limit...just to see the hybrid sign. whats up with this? my gas mileage is about 35 mpg on 1st tank. the interior is sub par but the mileage is better than my exploer. i paid 300 under invoice but got screwed on my trade. good luck.
6 years ago
Well this is my first post here and it is about as off topic as can be so I am sorry...
I need to get some things straight that I just read about people comparing a V.W. to a Honda... deisel or not a dub may be one of the worst cars in terms of reliability and in dealer service... And before people start the flame up let me finish... I have owned in the past ( in order)
G.T.I. 16 v....................great car and reliable
87 civic........................ most reliable car ever
91 accord......................see above
z24.............................. garbage
94 probe gt...................oh god bad
98 camry......................rock solid
00 bonneville ssei..........fast but expensive to keep
01 celica gts..................2 engines and a lemon law claim
01 highlander................very nice but SMALL
01 Civic........................solid but SLOOOW
02 camry...................still have and solid
02 jetta.....................9 unresolved problems w/run around
03 passat...................Horrific issues electrical problems
04 solara...................minor issues
04 toureg...................dont even ask
05 accord (hybrid).......1600 miles and great
Now to my point:
someone posted how great the TDI jetta is and then pulled some Costs to own out his @$$ ... Well they are WAY off
The Jetta has one of the worst ( Real life ) resale values in its class... and is very problematic ( check out consumer reports and others ).
I ran out of gas on the way to the dealer 3 times with the jetta because the fuel door wouldn't open and there is no manual release ( nice engineering )
The passat was not only slow and boring for a touring sedan but it had major electrical issue and 10% of the time the climate control would just go wacky...
The Toureg was just a joke... it spent 110 days in the shop in its first 6 months...
V.W. dealers are the pits on top of it all... they would never provide a car to drive and they wouldnt step up and help me try to resolve the problems with the manufacturer...I had to sue VW via the lemon law to get my money back for that POS...At least when we had problems with our celica ,Toyota stepped up and took care of the problem with no hassels and gave us a Highlander at cost ( true cost $18k for the limited ) and gave us full purchase price back for the celica.
If you want a reliable , fuel efficient car than VW is not even in the race ... dont believe me than go to www.vwvortex.com and read about all the issues that are plaguing their cars
6 years ago
Just went from 65 down to 22 here in SW Michigan.
My Honda Accord Hybrid went from 23.9 city to
21.5!
Some say that what's the advantage to a hybrid in winter then? I say ... ALL cars get worse mileage in the cold weather!!!
We (the early adapters) are MORE AWARE of our
performance 'cause we keep track obsessively.
6 years ago
I LIVE IN MN . AT 20 ABOVE I GET IN CITY 35-40 AND ON THE HIWAY I GET 56-60 . ABOVE 50 DEGREES I GET 48-50 IN CITY AND HAVE GOT 62.5 I HAVE O5 HCH I DRIVE WITH THE CRUISE CONTROL SET AT 60 MPH I HAVE THE 5 SPEED MANUAL
6 years ago
Problems with my 3-month old '05 HCH in 20F degree (and colder) weather:
ice crystals form on the interior surface of all windows
battery is running extremely low (3 "bars")
occasional scary "crunching" when braking on snowy roads
occasional stalls when downshifting
decreased mileage
--
Any thoughts on this??
6 years ago
I live in Grand Rapids, MI. I own a 2003 HCH (80,000 miles now) and have been VERY impressed w/ its ability to achieve 49.5 mpg lifetime fuel economy. I've NEVER had any battery problems w/ the Nickel-Metal Hydride batteries, and I LOVE how the car doesn't rely on the regular battery under the hood during startup.
I work in AAA MI's roadside assistance center here in GRapids, and I've never seen a HCH in need of a jumpstart. :-) The car does lose some efficiency (about 2-3 mpg, depending on how cold it is) in the winter months but it doesn't bother me. I know that every car loses MPG when it's cold. Yes, keeping the tire pressure up IS important during the winter AND summer months.
As for the "Hybrid vs. Diesel" issue, I agree that we're on the same side. It is only a matter of time until Honda and/or Toyota produce a "Hybrid-Diesel" that delivers truly STUNNING mpg ratings. I'm excited about that, and I'm sure it will be the next "drive system" type that I purchase.
As for the HCH in cold conditions, I believe that we HCH drivers need to realize that speeds between 50 and 60 mph are BEST for achieving approximately 50 mpg. AVOID jack-rabbit starts AND COAST WHEN YOU CAN- drive like you don't have brakes! Even when it's COLD outside, you can boost efficiency by setting the heater on the 2nd or 3rd LOWEST fan setting (avoid auto) AND by using the defrosters only as needed (use auto here as it is much faster...). One thing that I'd like to point out is the simple fact that during summer months the AC can POSITIVELY kill your mpg. Only use it when you have to. I've actually went 710 miles on the HCH's 13.3 gallon tank during August! I captured that stellar # on the dashboard w/ my camera phone and still have the picture.
As for the "quality and reliability" issue, I've never had ONE problem w/ the engine or CVT transmission in the HCH, and I change my engine oil every 8,000 miles. Take your HCH to your Honda dealer for the oil changes. The synthetic oil used is GREAT oil and it lasts MUCH longer under almost ANY driving condition, in my opinion. My MPG has BARELY even dropped recently, and I'm almost at 8K miles since my last oil change. I've been VERY impressed w/ the reliability and durability of this vehicle. I'm also impressed w/ the EBD (Electronic Braking Distribution) while on snow and ice. It really does slow you down FASTER than traditional ABS systems, even w/ the smaller tires. Impressive. I am now a loyal Honda owner, and I do believe that GM and Ford have some SERIOUS catching up to do. :-)
I believe that I am one of many HHOs-Happy Hybrid Owners. I truly believe that the # of people such as I can only continue to grow, as long as positive word-of-mouth continues to sell these wonderful vehicles. If you haven't had good luck w/ your hybrid, then it is LIKELY that you need to change your driving technique.
6 years ago
I'm a 05 HCH owner, w/ over 20,000 miles on it in less than 7 months....and I live in Vermont. When the weather is in the 20's (nearing 30) I can easily get 44 MPG on a 45 min. commute at highway speeds (I only have one stop light, and at the time of day I leave it's blinking!). Thats with Nokia snow tires on...I have no beef w/ the mileage...it's what I expected.
The diesel debate is useless for me, I cannot buy a new diesel in Vermont or neighboring states...and I wouldn't buy a VW after what I've seen of my friend's engine gumming up....
6 years ago
Just got a '06 honda civic hybrid 2 weeks ago, read through the manual, interesting that it states" the hybid system will NOT work in cold conditions until the batteries warm up,(this is done to protect the batteres), also that the hybrid system will NOT work in extreme heat until approx 15 minutes have passed" (also to protect the batteries)
I bought the car to drive around this little town, sure enough, the hybrid assist does not work until I have driven about 5 minutes on very cold days. It also doesn't recharge the batteries while stopping until the hybrid system wakes up. My trips are the 5 minute type.
Ya think the dealer would tell you this?
6 years ago
I have a 04 HCH with ~30K miles and have driven it through 2 summers and 2 winters. I live in SLC, Ut (el. ~4500 feet) and we have cold winters. I am a conservative driver (that's why I bought an HCH in the first place) and follow recommended hybrid driving habits. During the summer months I average about 37 mpg in the city and on the road (driving around Utah) ~40 mpg. In the winter months I average 27 -29 mpg in the city and 36-37 mpg on the road. My overall grand average milage under all driving conditions since I bought the car is 39 mpg. When I read about HCH drivers getting 40+ mpg in winter climates and commonly 45 - 50 mpg on the road in the summer, I wonder if I have a problem with my car or folks are inflating their milage. What I find really disconcerting; however, is that when I have asked the question to service managers at the dealer: "What kind of milage are local people getting with their Hybids here in SLC during the winter?", I get the same answer: "Ya know, I don't really know." I suspect that HCH drivers can expect to get similar results to what I get if they live at hight altitude and experience cold winters. I just wish Honda and their dealers would own up to the reality and when selling the cars to innocent victoms (perhaps too strong) tell them the truth instead of them buying the car and expecting to get 47 mpg in the city and 50 mgp on the road. I also would enjoy hearing from HCH drivers who live in similar enviroments and find out what kind of milage you get. I am not sure I will buy another Hybrid, since the difference in milage I get with my current Hybrid compared to the milage I got in my 2001 Civic does not warrant it. The original cost difference plus the fact that gas would probably need to get up to $5 per gallon to make up for the difference and the lack of power are all factors which will discourage me from buying a new hybrid.
Chris A.
6 years ago
To Brrrr who has ice crystals on the inside of all windows - the odds are that you are keeping your heater on "recirculate." I have only had window fogging problems (with all types of cars) when inadvertently driving around with the heat on recirculate. In my experience, that would have nothing to do with any unique characteristics of the HCH. Make sure the light is out on the recirc button (the left one) and that heated fresh air should solve your problem pronto.
6 years ago
Reply to Chris A. in Salt Lake City - I live in Glenwood Springs, CO and drive an 05 HCH - right now I am averaging a hair over 46.0 overall, but have only had the car 10.5 months. The overall was nearly 47 in early November, but winter tires and cold temps definitely drop the mileage a bit. I never warm the car up more than about 15 seconds before driving, and, while I'm very cognizant of getting good mileage, I think I drive it about like I would drive any car with limited power. Most of my commute is on highway at speeds under 65, which definitely helps the mileage. My overall includes several trips over to the Denver or Fort Collins areas and back, including a couple in the winter. The biggest drag on my overall mileage was a summer trip to Iowa and back - 80 mph in 95 degree weather has produced the lowest mileage I've seen (39 to 43). My wife has been driving an 03 HCH for over three years now, and her experience has been similar to mine. Her mileage drops a lot more than mine in the winter, but she has a short, mostly city commute, and also has a penchant for long warm-ups!
6 years ago
I have an 06 HCH that is getting around 35. I am past the first oil chande and I learned to drive my friend's Prius before I bought my HCH. The car has been back to the dealer 3 times for engine error codes. Sometimes the car's IMA locks out the starter and the car won't move! Honda will not tell the dealer what the codes mean. The response from Honda has been, "It sucks to be you!" I wish Toyota would make the Prius faster. I have owned 2 Corrollas and both cars got better mileage and lasted 200,000 miles without any engine lights. From what I've been told I am stuck with this occasional paperweight! First and last Honda EVER!
What I would like to see next year is a bybrid that uses E85. (Ford Escape would be a great start.)
I live in Wisconsin. I never had a drop in mpg with my Toyotas in winter. Even down to -10F. I commonly used ethanol blend which is the only thing most gas companies will add to fuel in the winter. From 10 years and around 150,000 miles of driving below 32F, I can tell you that the winter mpg drop is false for most regular fuel gas engines. Hybrids have a significant drop. That comes from the fact that low temperatures DO have a severe impact on batteries and other electrical systems. There is a reason that SEARS always bragged about how their DIEHARDs would start every time in Int'l Falls, MN. It's because its hard for a battery to do anything at -10F!
I have also lived 3 years in Europe and can tell you a thing or two about European Diesels. The whole continent of Europe lives under a smog cloud worse than LA on a hot August day. Even the newest micro-engined VWs produce more exhaust than 5 American SUVs. They do get extremely good mileage, however much of this comes from European diesel fuel which doe not meet EPA requirements. Also, the large majority of those diesel drivers are in the developed and warmer regions of Europe. Even the most advanced Benz or BMW will not start if its engine block heater is not plugged in when the temp drops below 0 F. (Hybrid in Jan... No Plug! Diesel in Jan... Hmmm?)
In Wisconsin, diesel requires all sorts of additives in the winter to keep it from geling. The State Patrol often fines truck drivers if they stall on the interstate because of the wrong fuel. Fuel economy for diesels drops significantly in winter and there is the added cost of electricity for 10 hours every night or a heated garage during the highest energy use months of the year.
Just some thoughts.
From Wisconsin: NO DIESEL... NO PLUG
5 years ago
I've had my '06 HCH for about a month and 900 ish miles. MPG has been disappointing, ranging from high 30's up to 46 or so on a 2 hour highway trip. My 45 minute, mostly highway commute just got 37 mg today at fill up. I;m a conservative driver, whats up with this? No defrost or other A/C use and tires at 40 psi. I hope it gets better in the spring.
5 years ago
Mike if you are looking for tips take a look here:
http://www.greenhybrid.com/learn/article/2-achieving-high-fuel-efficiency.html
They, and along with other techniques brought my '04 HCH from the upper 40's to 50's, and last summer averaged 65MPG, with my own personal record tank of 69.2MPG and 941 miles.
This mild Atlanta winter have averaged upper 50's.
These same tips have raised our Grand Caravan up from 15-16MPG to the low 20's.
Congradulations on driving conservatively, and it is helpful to know what is effective- and what is not.
5 years ago
I have an 03 HCH with 39000 miles in NE PA. I have never had a problem with any part of the car. It has been getting 49 mpg in the summer and 46 in the winter. I put on aggressive snow tires in the winter that seem to be a major cause my mileage dropping.
I've found that adding tire air pressure to a point , using synthetic oil, and driving conservatively are all good techniques to squeek the best from the car.
I am going to by a new one this week. and plan to sell my old one to my son.
5 years ago
I'm thinking about purchasing a Civic Hybrid, after many years in a now very rusty but still reliable Toyota Camry. My concern for winter driving is not fuel efficiency, but safety. The Camry has been a dream in our harsh central New York winters. Those of you who live in serious winter conditions and own a Civic Hybrid - how does it handle in the snow and ice? Can I put studded snow tires on it?
Thanks!
Diana
5 years ago
I had an old 81' civic with a 1300 engine that got 38 MPG around town and over 40 on the hwy.
I live in NJ and that was before the winter blends where introduced here. I never noticed a big drop in gas milage in the winter, sure there was probably some, but not enough to crrry about, and i only paid $500 for it, needed an clutch though?
5 years ago
"Those of you who live in serious winter conditions and own a Civic Hybrid - how does it handle in the snow and ice? Can I put studded snow tires on it?"
I live in the Colorado mountains, and can tell you that the Civic Hybrid handles snow and ice pretty much like any other small front-wheel-drive vehicle, including the Camry. The biggest difference is the engine braking that results from the hybrid system - it can cause the front wheels to skid slightly when you let off the gas on a slippery surface. Not a real problem, but it's good to be aware of it.
You could put studded snow tires on it, but do yourself and the roads a favor and get Blizzak-type studless tires instead. They have almost all of the ice traciton of studs without the constant howling. The Bridgestone Blizzak and Dunlop Graspic are the most commonly available examples of these. The Dunlops are a little cheaper; I have used both, and find the Dunlops every bit as good as the Blizzaks.
For the best winter handling and safety, use snow tires on all four wheels. The difference is huge.
5 years ago
The new (2006) HCH won't "autostop" at temps below -12C in winter or above something in the region of ( I recall) 38 Deg C in summer.
2 years ago
For what it's worth, here are my numbers
Bought 2008 Honda Civic Hybrid (July 1st, 2008)
Overall Fuel Economy to Date: 6.4 l /100 km (37 mpg)
Total distance traveled: 15000 km (Approx. 40% highway @ 100 km/hr)
Winter Fuel Economy: 9.0 l/100 km (26 mpg)
Winter Distance traveled: 1500 km (Approx. 40% highway @ 100 km/hr)
Winter period driven: Jan 3rd 2009 - Feb 13th 2009
It's been brutally cold here in Ottawa for the period, high of 7.8 C on Feb 11th, -30 C on Jan 16th with several days below -20 C
2 years ago
Try this, it should help especially in our cold Canadian climate:
http://www.cleanmpg.com/forums/showthread.php?t=17560
...and this:
http://www.cleanmpg.com/forums/showthread.php?t=18185
Cheers;
MSantos
2 years ago
The auto-stop wouldn't work if you use front defroster. I found out the auto-stop works if you cycle the mode to front defroster together with directing air flow to your feet.
2 years ago
We live in Northern New England. Between the winter blend of gas, snow tires and colder temperatures our mileage drops from 52 to 55 mpg to 45 to 48 mpg during the winter months. Our HCH is a 2005 with a manual transmission.
MJB
1 year ago
[url=http://xsp.pl]szablony allegro[/url]szablony allegro.
50 weeks ago
how about in canada -35 is there big effect on the gas?
Post a new comment