skip to content

Bucking

Created January 24, 2005, at 5:00 pm by Anonymous

I drive a Civic Hybrid daily and it is having problems. When I try to pass or go up a slight hill the car "bucks". The dealer says its the EGR valve, but we changed it twice with no luck fixing the problem. Any suggestions.

Thanks
Rob

Anonymous

7 years ago

Your car shouldn't do that.
I'd call a meeting with your dealer's service manager and give them one more chance to fix it once and for all.

If it still isn't fixed I'd request a meeting with the regional service manager.

Anonymous

7 years ago

I have had the problem you are describing as well, but only in standard hydraulic automatic transmissions. The solution to my problem was a low level of transmission fluid. Apparently, since transmission fluid is what turns the splines in a torque converter (and since I didn't have enough), there wasn't enough pressure in the fluid at relatively low rpm's (for example, in overdrive).

A CVT should not be subject to this bucking, as it is a mechanical linkage. A standard manual transmission uses mechanical linkage as well, but a slipping clutch can cause a bucking sensation. What kind of transmission do you have? What gear are you in when you experience the sensation? Is it a repeated sensation, or is it just one time, and then it doesn't happen until the next time you try to pass someone or go up a hill?

Anyone who blames the EGR for a bucking sensation is an idiot. EGR stands for exhaust gas recirculator, and is only serves to assist in warming an engine up to proper operating temp. After the engine reaches a proper operating temperature, the EGR turns itself off. It's not big enough to cause any bucking of any kind, and isn't important enough to dramatically affect the operation of the engine (the EGR on my Camaro broke off...hehehe...rattles a little, takes longer to warm up, but it sure as hell doesn't "buck").

Anonymous

6 years ago

I have had the same problem and the EGR valve was to blame as well. They changed it and it still does it. They took the transmission apart and put a part in and it is still bucking and slipping. The dealer told me that I have a lot of mileage on my warrantee and to wait and to see if it gets worse. I love the car and the MPG but the transmission as to go. I have owned the car for less than a year and it have been ion the shop over six times.

Anonymous

6 years ago

My 04 HCH started doing this just before the 30K maint schedule. The schedule includes a CVT fluid change and it fixed the problem.

Anonymous

6 years ago

We have flushed the transmission several times, added new parts and it still will do it. The next thing would be to put a new transmission in. They do not want to do that until later. This morning I thought I was going to walk it started to buck very badly. But it came out of it. Like I said we love the car and the mileage but the transmission has to be reviewed by Honda, since I am not the only person with a problem.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Well, I'm definitely not a mechanic....hehehe...but...and this is a hypothetical....

If the electronics component that is designed to smoothly add electric boost isn't "smoothly" adding that boost, then it may produce the bucking sensation you are experiencing.

When it starts to buck, is it repetitive, like rhythmic, or is it just random, spaced out whenever?

Anonymous

6 years ago

It bucks from a stopped to a start and sometimes a dragging sound-vibration.

Anonymous

6 years ago

"They do not want to do that until later. "
"The dealer told me that I have a lot of mileage on my warrantee and to wait and to see if it gets worse."

Terry, if it were me I'd insist on having a meeting with the regional service manager.
You've had this problem WAY too long.

Those dealer quotes are not acceptable, at least not to me. Sounds like they are playing on your good will, trusting nature and patience.
Your car isn't going to fix itself. Why wait?

Under warranty?
I'd want the car fixed in a week tops into perfect driving condition.

Don't let them put you off & send you away for another day.

Anonymous

6 years ago

yeah, i second that. "Warranty" does not mean "see if it gets any worse." I work in the service industry, and when my customers purchase a product with a warranty and something goes wrong, they demand service, and pronto. And I agree with them. They deserve it.

No one puts out $20,000 - $40,000 worth of brand new car, and then be expected to just "see if it gets any worse." Trust me, no one would think bad of you if you raised a stink at this point. (I'm kinda hoping you do...hehehe!) If the dealer doesn't take care of the issue, with a quickness, get a lawyer, cause they don't have a leg to stand on.

Better yet, post the phone number of the dealership. I'm sure the gracious ppl here at hybridcars.com wouldn't mind giving their $.02 to the service department there. ;)

Anonymous

6 years ago

Thanks everone. They have just told me that Honda not the dealer has the say so in what is replaced. Do you know if this is true. I would hate to tell everyone that they are in Quincy IL.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Yeah pretty much. Dealers don't pay for warranty repairs. The way it works is they get authorization for the repair from Honda NA, then once authorized, they do the repair and send the bill to Honda North America. If Honda NA does not authorize the repair, the dealer's not going to do anything they can't get paid for.

Anonymous

6 years ago

That might actually work to your favor, because instead of the dealer's service techs working on the problem, you'll have Honda's engineers working on the problem.

Anonymous

6 years ago

I own a 2003 Civic Hybrid and am having significant transmission problems at 27,000. I took it in for significant vibration noise, it sounded like the front in was going to fall off. They changed the rack and pinion, but screwed up the transmission in the process. At 35, the transmission sounded like a thousand mequitos. The whine is so bad, driving it more than 30 miles will drive you nuts. The dealership changed the transmission once, and the whine starts at 50. America Honda Corp is now saying all transmissions whine to some degree so good luck. Are any of you having an ear splitting whine at 50mph?

Bruce

Anonymous

6 years ago

I have 33K on my '04 and the CVT is quiet as a mouse.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Actually I recently noted my 03 HCH (CVT) started being what I called "jerky" at very low RPM's, brought it in today, dealer replaced the EGR. Certainly seems to have gone away. Course it cost $447.00. BTW, I have 69500 miles on it.

Hope this fixes it.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Just received my 03 CVT back from dealer. According to American Honda Representative, All Hybrid CVT transmissions WHINE, like a dentist drill and Honda will not fix it. Does anyone know where to get some good earplugs?

Bruce

Anonymous

6 years ago

I have always heard a slight "whine" when slowing down, sorta sounds like a police siren in the distance. at least that is what others have said when riding. but it is very faint, sorry to hear yours is like that all the time, that would be a PITA

Anonymous

6 years ago

WOO HOO!!!
I got a new transmission and the problem is solved. Definately Honda needs to look at the design.

I ended up calling American Honda and they talked with the dealer. I recommend this to anyone who is having problems with thier dealer.
I believe the number is 1-800-999-1009.

Good luck.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Congratulations on your perseverance & new transmission!

good warning shot too. i haven't heard of many reliability issues with the honda or toyota's.

see ya

Anonymous

6 years ago

All of your comments are interesting. I have the same problem with my 2003 Hybird. The man told me the EGR was bad and that caused the bucking. However, at the same time he drained and refilled my transmission fluid which I have been told by another service department can cause the problem. He also told me that Honda has a new transmission fluid that is different and is supposed to be better.
Bottom line when he replaced the fluid and disconnected the EGR it stopped bucking. I have also found that the EGR is on national backhold so someone is selling the #$%^&* out of them I guess. Either that or they are replacing a lot of them under warranty.

Anonymous

6 years ago

i had the bucking problem, they replaced my EGR valve and life is good.

Anonymous

6 years ago

I am having the same issues with 82,000 miles with the bucking. The dealer told me it might be the EGR valve and they could replace it. I called a local radio auto guy and he told me that Hondas are notorious for having EGR clogging and that all I should have to do is clean the EGR system. Then, the IML light came on. I took it back to the dealer and had to have the catalytic converter replaced (luckily under warranty). Everything seemed better until I took a long trip a week later, and the bucking is back. I am going to try to have the EGR system cleaned as a first resort. I am starting to get upset with my car spending more time going up and down than forward and backward!

Anonymous

6 years ago

I have recently designed a new computer program which will improve the efficiency of convential combustion engines substantially.
http://www.aussiecarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=3154

It seems to me it is the inefficiency of the convential engine that has to be addressed before expecting too much of it as a hybrid. I suspect that there is some mechanical imbalance created possibly due to friction!
It would be my advice that hybrid vehicles should adopt my system of engine monitoring. This will ensure that cylinders are fueled more efficiently and I susect your current problems would disappear!

Anonymous

6 years ago

I can tell the person with 82000 miles that Honda recommends that the transmission fluid for the CVT be replaced every 30000 miles. I have found that if you go over 50000 miles the car will start bucking. I am not sure if the oil causes that, but when I changed the oil the first time it stopped. I can also say at that time that the EGR was not acting up according to the service department. If you are truly having problems with the transmission you should contact the American Honda phone number in the message above. My car is out of warranty and they have arranged to have my catalytic converter replaced for half price under "courtesy work" so I am not as sad.

Anonymous

6 years ago

I have just completed the replacement of the EGR valve that was turned off and also the replacement of the Cat. Converter. The dealer and American Honda did as they promised and gave me a real good deal on all of the parts and work. Although it did cost me $800 the converter was $1100 quoted for just the part from another dealer.

I can say that everything is very good with my car again.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Oh, yeah, I've had the transmission fluid replaced already. I had some problems with that after I had it done at Jiffy Lube. Then I found out from the dealer that using another fluid messes things up. Had to go through that a few times because one dealer only changed the fluid a few times. Another dealer realized that a full flush was needed to completely get rid of the "wrong" fluid. That was a totally different feeling than this time around, though.

I did, however, just get my car back from a seperate mechanic who replaced my EGR valve. When I dropped the car off, I was told that the runners needed to be cleaned, no biggie. But then I got a call and they said it was in fact the valve. It did "only" cost me $311 instead of the over $400 the dealer was going to charge.

Anonymous

6 years ago

I am not sure where you are living, however I was out of state in Cincinnati, Ohio at a place called Performance Honda. The people there were very honest. The lead mechanic priced out the change of the EGR for parts and labor it came to $287 which I though was high and at that I had to wait for the part to arrive as they were on national back order.

However, if you talk with American Honda at the number listed above you may get some help.

Anonymous

6 years ago

Hi Hybrid owners,

I would like to help you with your hybrid problems.
First on the list is your bucking complaint, if your car bucks on take off or at a cruise your problem may be the egr valve. I have repaired hundreds
of hybrids with this complaint, if the egr valve fails
to fix it I drive the car with a h.d.s scanner and monitor the start clutch and the forward clutch.
There are several tsb's on these types of problems
and on occation a new cvt trans is the fix.

Anonymous

6 years ago

My HCH ('03) with about 84,000 mi on it is in the shop with the bucking problem, and they told me its the EGR, and the good news for me is that HondaCare will cover it. This problem is the same as I experienced prior to my last service, when they did an upgrade to the engine computer under a recall, and that fixed it initially.

Still getting good mileage though, as the weather turns cooler, my last tank was 48.8 mpg, even with the bucking problem, which only occurs at low speeds.

In another bit of good news, they're doing my first brake job on the car. I've gotten 84,000 mi. (about 60% highway/ 40%city) out of the original equipment front brake pads. The regenerative brake system seems to make the pads last longer, since the electric motor puts an immediate drag on the engine when you take your foot off the accelerator...

Anonymous

5 years ago

Help!! I have 93,000 on my HCH and I have to putin a third new Catalytic converter. I may not know a lot about cars, but a new Catalytic Coverter very 30,000 does not sound right ot me!

Anonymous

5 years ago

I am having weiered problem with my HCH, I got my transmission fluid changed last week and two days later it started giving me a grinding sound when starting from hault and then its all okay!!!

Wondering what it can be ? I have 100,000 miles its 2004... I believe Honda should do something about this...

ANy suggestions what should I DO?

Anonymous

5 years ago

I have 212000 km on my 03 civic, did the routine maintence and its been fairly good. for the past six months. On e dealer quotes a new tranny replacment for $6000 CND.
I've been surfing forums and have also heard of Tranny fluid change or ECG valve. I dicounted the valve on the account that I can reproduce 'bucking' or 'vibration' at diferent RPM and torque and also at certain points during regenerative breaking.
I took my car into a different dealership and requested a fluid change, they suggested a full Flush to really clean it out. This resolved all bucking and vibration. Dealer recomends full flush every 60000 km.
who new?

Anonymous

5 years ago

I just took my 2003 Honda Civic Hybrid into the shop yesterday because the "check engine" light was on and it was bucking at very low speeds such as in parking lots and in slow traffic, and they are telling me that I need to have one of my catalytic converters replaced. I would be able to swallow the $1500 price tag better (I have almost 105,000 miles on the car so fixing the thing gets more pricey as the age goes up I have accepted), but this is the 2nd cat. converter that I have had to had replaced! And from what I have read about them they usually don't EVER need to be replaced, and now my car has gone through two of them!
I am not getting any answers from my dealer as far as the cause so, does anyone know why this is happening?

Anonymous

5 years ago

My 2003 HCH had the low speed bucking problem that started at 30,000 miles. The delaer replaced the EGR and that fixed the problem, although I don't think it was "as good as new".

Recently I have been experiencing hesitation when placing in drive or reverse and slipping of the transmission when starting. Today the delaer told me I needed to have the start clutch replaced.

Anonymous

5 years ago

My 03 civic hybrid was bucking for the last 4 or 5 months when accelerating from stop. I took the car in for 80k mile service last weekend and also had my transmission fluid flushed... The bucking is gone.

I requested to have the egr valve replaced/cleaned/checked but they said they won't look at it unless the check engine light comes on or the diagnostic computer reports a problem w/ the egr valve.

Anonymous

5 years ago

My 2003 HCH had the same "buck" mostly comping out of a stop position...

Regular 30,000 CVT fluid changes with Honda fluid fixed mine every time! The car told me it was time to change it with the buck.

I never had to change anything else major (besides tires) - and just traded it in at 108,000.

Post a new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.